Score: 7

"hmmmmm.....meh"

submission: Killer Kazuki: S.E.

date: December 23, 2004

So why exactly was this "special edition" released. Besides backrounds being redrawn and that section where he's reminiscing after he gets the sword in him it's essentially unchanged except for no longer having the boring ass beginning. If you lost all the extras that should have been included there was no reason for this.

Score: 4

"Ever wonder where IWP gets his ideas?"

submission: No Christmas For You!

date: December 16, 2004

Remember that South Park episode that from 1997 that said everything that this is. Way to shoot for originality IWP.

Score: 3

"meh"

submission: DBZ Technique Test

date: December 15, 2004

They look like they are sprites ripped from a DBZ game, but I'm not really qualified to make that decision. If you really had the talent to make that yourself you shouldn't be wasting it making crappy DBZ cartoons

Score: 3

"Hmmmm"

submission: lol delete please

date: December 12, 2004

I've seen alot of these, must be part of a tutorial. Right?

Score: 7

"So damn cutesy"

submission: ILoveEgg-Merry Xmas~

date: December 9, 2004

That was so saccharine that I now have diabetes. No one can really argue with the graphics nice as always, but the only way I can properly define the I Love Egg cartoons is that it just is, no real storylines no sense of continuity, it just is.

Score: 7

"Terrible music oy"

submission: The Amazing Photon 3

date: December 7, 2004

This is a neat idea and the game is fun not the most challenging but still fun. The level design was ok nothing to write home about, but the music destroyed this game. Honestly that was the worst song I've heard is a long time. Could you please change it?

Score: 6

"I'm not a foamy fan"

submission: Amityville Toaster

date: December 3, 2004

But these are definetlly better when you have something random going on than when you are trying to make a statement about something.

Score: 5

"The major fault is is the lack of humor."

submission: One Ring to Rule ThemAll3

date: November 30, 2004

I think it's time for you to start working on something original. Two years ago you were inspiring alot of viewers and fellow animators but things change and not all things that seemed funny stay that way. (well I guess they do for some people)
One of the main things that held this back was that the humor just wasn't all that humorous. The jokes about lord of the rings were geared too much towards fanboys and most of the other humor even when it was clever was either cliched or just not interesting. One other thing that ruined the delivery of alot of jokes was sauron he is just annoying. his presentatio was understandable when it was in a quick little joke animation but it grates in long viewing periods.
I was upset that none of the characters were improved graphically from the last film while it's still better looking than 90% of other movies on newgrounds you'd still expect improvement. Also the animation didn't seem natural, too stiff.

Score: 7

"Graphically nice, but lacking overall"

submission: Crazy Horse!

date: November 30, 2004

Is was cute and very nice to look at, but i felt like the jokes weren't executed very well. Something this style could have benefited from more rapid fire jokes and some references to western movies. Plus it could have used more western style, not just in look, but in the way the scenes played out.

Score: 4

"Flawed, entertaining none the less."

submission: asdasdddvvvcxvcxvcvcx

date: November 30, 2004

I think the best thing you could do is have it create random mazes everytime so people would have a reason to pla it more than once. Also a little backround music, mabey something jazzy, would make it interesting also the blue circle should move more smoothly.